The best Cookies by sooty.m on Eaten
Cookies
43 reviews
REALLY GOOD
1st PISTACHIO AND CHERRY AMARETTI
Dolcetti, Kilsyth
Pistachio and cherry amaretti cookie
2nd BANANA EVERYTHING COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
While we’re still on the subject of muffin 🍌🍌🍌, these are also very good.
3rd TWIN DRAGON ALMOND COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
I don’t think I’ve actually had the ones by Main On Foods but Todd Wilbur’s attempt to replicate the original recipe (c. 1951) is impressive.
4th THE WORLD’S BEST ANZAC BISCUITS
Soots Cook Nook, Private
According to the AWW anyway. I don’t know that they are since it’s my first time baking them and I don’t eat them very often. But I can attest to them being highly addictive and far superior to the few commercially produced ones I’ve had. They’re wonderfully caramel-ly and this is nicely complemented by the addition of nutty oats and coconut.
5th BAILEYS IRISH CREAM CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
A year ago, I baked Bailey’s Irish cream Cheesecake during a pretty shit week for humanity. A year later, here we are again, in a similar situation which many of us (if we are so fortunate) are trying to ameliorate with the healing power of baking. Again, can’t really go wrong with Baileys in a product we already love that is the chocolate chip cookie.
6th ALMOND SHORTBREAD COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Buttery and nutty in that special almondy way. 😋
7th NEEDLESS MARKUP $250 COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Milk chocolatey cookies chock full of oats, semi-sweet chocolate chips, pecans, walnuts, almonds. Made milk chocolatey by the addition of shaved Hershey bars. No idea where this urban legend recipe really came from since the story about a woman paying $250 for the recipe at Neiman Marcus was a hoax. Still, not a bad cookie to have warmed and with a glass of cold milk.
8th GINGERY BROWNIE CRINKLE COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
It’s a @nytcooking Christmas cookie day! I like em’ most when they’re fresh out of the oven and the chocolate chips are “still luxuriously liquidy.”
9th CHERRY CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Because I been getting hungry at night with no snacks to turn to other than water (or leftovers from lunch/dinner). It’s high time freezer cookie dough made a comeback in my life.
10th THE ULTIMATE BUTTER COOKIES (SOME SAY, IT TASTES LIKE JENNY BAKERY!)
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Buttery, melt-in-your mouth and just downright addictive! And no, they’re not mashed spuds. #onemore #inmymouth
11th THIN AND CRISPY CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Happy National Chocolate Chip Day! These were a really quick and easy excuse to dispose of an open bag of chocolate chips. The pay off was a batch of caramelized butterscotch-y cookies with thin, crispy rims and chewy centers. Took under 20 minutes!
12th PINEAPPLE TARTS
Mamma Shob’s Kitchen, Private Location
Homemade! Glad I didn’t have to pay premium 💰 to enjoy them!
13th SALTED CHOCOLATE CHUNK SHORTBREAD COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
It took me a while to finally try those choc chunk shortbread cookies that were trending...a year ago? I couldn’t make them happen as log cookies (they were uncuttable), so I defaulted to drop cookie mode. They don’t look perfectly round and I didn’t use salted butter but they were still delicious. Yum! 🍪🍪🍪 #darkchocolate #lindt #chocolatechunk #shortbread #maldonseasalt #demerarasugar #cookies #alisoneroman #newyorktimescooking #fromscratch #weekendbake #sootybakes 👩🏻‍🍳
14th BROWN BUTTER BOURBON PECAN CHOCOLATE CHUNK COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Sweet, salty, crunchy, gooey, and BOOZY…YES, you can have it all. 🍪🥃 #brownbutter #pecans #butteredpecans #cinnamon #darkbrownsugar #kentuckystraightbourbonwhiskey #woodfordreserve #darkchocolate #thebelgian #chocolatechunk #maldonseasalt #cookies #sootybakes 👩🏻‍🍳
15th CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
The pan-banging kind that gives you rippled edges that shatter in your mouth and them soft gooey centers. Yes, it took over a year for me to try these.
16th SHORTBREAD FINGERS WITH STEM GINGER
Crabtree & Evelyn, Singapore
In stark contrast to the C&E chocolate & hazelnut butter cookies, these were scrumptious. The stem ginger was an interesting yet delectable addition to an already wonderful buttery treat.
17th SOOTY’S ICED TEA COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
As in, they’re meant to taste like the tropics. You know, Thai iced tea, peach iced tea...mango...da kine... Da kine you might enjoy with 100% Kona coffee and with Ehukai singing the Moloka`i Slide. 🏝🍹
19th YO YO
Baked In Sorrento, Sorrento
Melt-in-your mouth shortbread cookies sandwiching what I think is a passion fruit icing?
20th GINGER & DARK CHOCOLATE COOKIE
Ben's Cookies, Singapore
Fiery cookie from the Scottish Highlands. No wonder it cost $3.
23rd PASSIONFRUIT YOYO
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Well, I made my own. They look different and are contingent upon amount of passionfruit juice in filling and temperature of cookie. This one looks pretty chuffed.
24th PASSIONFRUIT YOYO VERSION HARLEQUIN
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Sandwiching the filling with 2 hot cookies results in version Harlequin of the passionfruit yoyo.
25th DOUBLE CHOCOLATE COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Choc-full of choc. It’s like a really fudgy brownie with deep, unadulterated chocolate flavor. The most chocolaty cookie I’ve ever baked and eaten. Perhaps, a tad too intense for yours truly but definitely one for the chocoholics.
26th ROASTED CASHEW COOKIES WITH COFFEE AND CARDAMOM
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Melt-in-your-mouth coffee-cashew shortbread. Didn’t taste cardamom, so maybe I shouldn’t have halved the amount of cardamom.
27th BEST-EVER PINEAPPLE COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Don’t think these were the best I’d ever had (or made for that matter). But they were a hit with everyone else (so it’s probably me, haha). To their credit, they were really buttery and melt-in-your mouth.
28th THUMBPRINT COOKIES
Los Floristas, AAB
I’m not sure what they’re called in Argentina but they sure look and taste like thumbprint cookies 👀
29th SOFT CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Today gave me a reason to rid myself of a bag of chocolate chips and some leftover cream cheese. Happy National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day! 🍪
30th LEMON CURD LINZER COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Finally rid the freezer of leftover shortcrust pastry (from pineapple tartlets of recent memory) and the chiller of some leftover lemon curd (from the latest babka).